I want to tell you about a seller I work with.
When we started together, he was all about the product.
He had redesigned it and made it better. He was proud of it, and he should have been.
But he didn’t have the cash to order it.
He’d already done the hard part most owners skip.
He’d cut expenses, he was running the business with real discipline, and he was still stuck because all of his marketing lived on Amazon.
That made sense because Amazon is where his customers were buying.
It’s probably where most of yours are buying too.
The Real Cost of Selling Only on Amazon
The problem is what that costs.
In our research report, The Secret to Thriving, Amazon-primary businesses paid a median of about 36% of revenue in all-in marketplace costs.
Shopify-primary businesses paid about 16%.
That gap is the money that funds new product, and he was living on the wrong side of it.
How He Started to Build Demand Off Amazon
So we asked a different question. How could he create demand off Amazon?
He had ideas, and he got to work.
This next part is the one most people struggle with.
For about six months, not much happened. He kept showing up anyway.
Then every so often, a video he made would catch on. A following started to build, and it kept building.
Last month, it showed up in his numbers in a big way. And he’s just getting started.
The Video Wasn’t the Turning Point
What I want you to see is that the video wasn’t the turning point.
The turning point was the six months he kept going when it wasn’t easy and nothing seemed to be working.
Our report found the same pattern in the businesses that are thriving.
They don’t leave Amazon, they just build demand where they control the message, and they let customers buy wherever they prefer.
Where to Start
You don’t have to launch a whole new channel to do this.
You can pick one place off Amazon where your customers already spend time and show up there every week.
Give it longer than feels comfortable.
Our report walks through three groups – struggling, healthy, and thriving – and what moves a business from one group to the next.
Read it and find out where you stand today.
Cyndi
Quick Summary
- The cost of staying Amazon-only: In Your Profit Team’s research report The Secret to Thriving, Amazon-primary ecommerce businesses paid a median of about 36% of revenue in all-in marketplace costs, compared with about 16% for Shopify-primary businesses.
- Why it matters: That 20-point gap is cash that could fund inventory and new product launches.
- The approach: Thriving sellers don’t leave Amazon. They build demand off Amazon, in places where they control the message, and let customers buy wherever they prefer.
- The real turning point: Consistency. One seller posted for about six months with little traction before his videos caught on and the results showed up in his numbers.
- Where to start: Pick one off-Amazon channel where your customers already spend time, show up every week, and give it longer than feels comfortable.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do Amazon sellers pay in marketplace costs?
In Your Profit Team’s The Secret to Thriving report, Amazon-primary businesses paid a median of about 36% of revenue in all-in marketplace costs, including fees and advertising. Shopify-primary businesses paid about 16%.
How can an Amazon seller build demand off Amazon?
Choose one channel outside Amazon where your customers already spend time, such as TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, or email, and publish there every week. You don’t need to launch a full new sales channel. The goal is to build an audience that knows you, while customers still buy wherever they prefer, including Amazon.
Should I leave Amazon to lower my marketplace fees?
No. The thriving businesses in Your Profit Team’s research didn’t leave Amazon. They reduced their dependence on Amazon advertising by creating demand in places they control, which improves profitability without giving up Amazon sales.
How long does it take for social media content to work for an ecommerce brand?
Often longer than owners expect. The seller in this story posted for about six months before his videos started catching on. Consistency through the slow stretch is what made the difference, not a single viral video.
How does building demand off Amazon help cash flow?
Lower marketplace and advertising costs leave more of each sale in the business. That cash can fund inventory orders and new products, so growth doesn’t depend on loans or squeezing expenses further.
Related reading: Blessed Are the Flexible · Am I Ready to Quit My Day Job? Is My Business Ready?
You don't have to figure it out alone. Your Profit Team gives ecommerce owners the financial clarity and support that make the hard parts of business feel lighter.
