How Do I Know If My Accounting System Is Giving Me Good Financial Data?

0 Comments

You open your financials before a big decision, and one number looks off.

You can’t quite put your finger on why, so you move on, because the decision is due and the number is probably fine.

It seems like a reasonable call because you’re busy, but good decisions need numbers you can trust, and there are three quick ways to find out if your numbers are at that point.

1. Are your bank accounts reconciled and current?

If reconciliation is months behind, everything built on top of it is shaky.

2. Does your gross margin make sense?

Based on my experience with ecom clients, it usually lands somewhere between 40 and 70 percent, depending on the product and the platform.

If yours looks wildly different, cost of goods sold may be miscategorized.

3. Does your balance sheet tell a coherent story?

Do the bank balances match what you see online, do the inventory numbers reflect what’s actually on your shelves, and does accounts receivable look reasonable for your business?

If any of those feel off, the books aren’t ready to steer by, and that’s the first thing to fix.

Where to start

Start with reconciliation, and look at the date of your last one.

If it’s been a while, work on catching those up. Then work on the next step.

If you’d like a second set of eyes on your numbers, Your Profit Team can help.

Cyndi


Quick Summary

Your accounting system is giving you good financial data when three things check out: your bank accounts are reconciled and current, your gross margin falls in a sensible range (typically 40–70% for ecommerce brands, depending on product and platform), and your balance sheet matches reality — bank balances, inventory on hand, and accounts receivable. If any of these look off, fix the books before making big decisions, starting with bank reconciliation.

  • Check 1: Bank reconciliations are up to date.
  • Check 2: Gross margin is in a realistic range; a wild number often means cost of goods sold (COGS) is miscategorized.
  • Check 3: Balance sheet figures match your bank, your shelves, and your receivables.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I tell if my financial statements are accurate?

Run three quick checks: confirm your bank accounts are reconciled through a recent month, compare your gross margin to what’s typical for your business model, and make sure your balance sheet matches real-world numbers like your online bank balances and physical inventory counts.

How often should an ecommerce business reconcile its bank accounts?

At least monthly. When reconciliation falls months behind, every report built on it — your P&L, cash flow, and margins — becomes unreliable for decision-making.

What is a normal gross margin for an ecommerce business?

In Cyndi Thomason’s experience working with ecommerce clients, gross margin usually lands between 40% and 70%, depending on the product and the sales platform. A margin far outside that range is often a sign that cost of goods sold is miscategorized.

What should I fix first if I don’t trust my numbers?

Start with bank reconciliation. Check the date of your last completed reconciliation, catch up any months that are behind, and then move on to reviewing gross margin and the balance sheet.

Who can review my ecommerce financials?

Your Profit Team is a fractional CFO advisory service for ecommerce brands, built on the Profit First methodology. The team can give your numbers a second set of eyes and help you get your books decision-ready.

Not sure your numbers are ready to steer by?

Book a discovery call and let Your Profit Team take a second look at your financials.

Book Your Discovery Call →

Related reading: Wisdom and Understanding: Profit vs. Cash Flow · More Revenue Isn’t Solving My Cash Problems — What Will?

About the author 

Cyndi Thomason

Cyndi is a mom and author of Profit First for Ecommerce Sellers and Motherhood, Apple Pie, and all that Happy Horseshit. She's also a speaker and thought leader in ecommerce accounting and Mom Entrepreneurship. Cyndi is the founder of Your Profit Team and bookskeep, which provide CFO advisory and Profit First accounting services to hundreds of ecommerce businesses around the world. When not helping business owners or her team, Cyndi can be found in her garden.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}